We compare independently. Some links are affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes our prices, order or verdicts. How we make money
Best SurePayroll alternatives in 2026
Looking for something other than SurePayroll? Below are 10 tools that do the same job, compared with SurePayroll's $20/month starting price. 1 of them start cheaper, 1 have a free plan. Ordered by our rating, never by commission.
SurePayroll what you have now
Online payroll for small businesses, from Paychex.
No free plan
$20/mo
All SurePayroll alternatives
- 2
- 3
$50/mo
Payroll that plugs straight into QuickBooks Online.
From $50/month
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
Quote
Payroll and HR from one of the largest US payroll providers.
Price on request
- 10
Quote
Payroll and HR services for small and mid-size businesses.
Price on request
How do you pick the right SurePayroll alternative?
It depends on why you're leaving. On a tight budget? Patriot Payroll has the lowest starting price in this list. Want to start free? Square Payroll has a free plan. Want the best all-rounder? Start with Gusto.
Before you switch
- Export your data from SurePayroll first (contacts, projects, invoices or tickets).
- Check when your SurePayroll contract renews; yearly plans usually don't refund unused months.
- Start a free trial of your top pick and import a small test set before you move everything.
See how we check prices, or compare every payroll software side by side on the Payroll software page.